GS4 · UPSC Mains

You have been appointed as the Chief Secretary in a state. Recently, a complex issue has surfaced involving two civil servants from your state. Both the officers who are known for their excellence in their respective roles have found themselves embroiled in an intense public feud on social media. Officer A initiated the dispute by posting a series of images and statements on social media, indirectly implying that Officer B has been utilizing personal relationships and networking for gaining undue advantages in job postings and promotions. This action, while unproven, has stirred up a storm of rumors, leading to severe reputational damage to Officer B. In response, Officer B defended herself on the same platform, accusing Officer A of unethical practices and breach of confidentiality. She went a step further by revealing his internal departmental issues, which Officer A was supposedly involved in. These allegations have not only escalated the conflict but also exposed sensitive information to the public. Officer A's social media posts have been prominently picked up and publicised by a local news outlet further escalating the situation. The issue has now gone beyond the realms of the state administration, leading to intense public speculation and media scrutiny. All these events have unfolded on a public platform and have tarnished the image of the civil services and created a disruption in the working of the state administration. The Central Government is closely monitoring the situation and has exerted pressure for appropriate disciplinary action against the officers involved. (a) What are ethical issues involved in this situation? (b) What are the options available to you as the Chief Secretary? (c) Which option would you choose and why?

5 toppers answered this

GS4 · Case studies on the above issues

See this question on Topper's Copy by Hashin →

More GS4 questions →